This week, I sat down with Lara O’Reilly, chief correspondent and CMO Insider newsletter anchor at Business Insider.
You’ve been a journalist for nearly two decades, writing for Marketing Week, Yahoo Finance, The Wall Street Journal, Digiday, and Business Insider. What are some of the stories you’re most proud of and why?
There’s a real range. Often, you file a story, and then you’re straight on to hunting down the next thing, and it’s rare that you look back and take stock. But if I do look back, some of the things I remember: 10 years ago, I won the Digital Journalist of the Year award from the London Press Club. The judges cited my interview with Kevin Roberts, chairman of the ad agency Saatchi & Saatchi at the time. I had a really wide-ranging interview with him. He was promoting a book at the time, and about half an hour in, I threw in this question about the lack of gender diversity in advertising agency leadership roles. He clapped back, saying that it’s not an issue at all, and lots of women don’t actually aspire to being in leadership, anyway. He said a lot of other controversial things after I kept pressing him on that issue. After we published it, he was immediately placed on leave by Publicis, the parent company, and he later apologized and resigned. It set off this really huge conversation around the world, which broke out beyond the ad industry to breakfast TV talk shows and made it to the national newspapers in New Zealand. It was a real agenda setter.
More recently, I was chronicling the rise and fall of an ad tech startup called MediaMath, and that took a lot of investigative work. I think it answers a lot of questions for people who were ultimately left out of pocket by its demise.
I did a Page One at The Wall Street Journal, where we made a big call that Amazon was going to become a big advertising giant. That turned out to be a good call. We had a good yarn a couple of years ago about this ad sales employee who figured out how to steal $9 million from his company’s Google ad account and attempted to buy gold bars with it. He did a lousy job of covering his tracks and was caught by the FBI, so that was a tale for the ages.
You worked for Business Insider in 2014 as a senior advertising editor for three years, and then left for The Wall Street Journal, writing the lauded CMO Today newsletter. Now you are back at Business Insider, writing its CMO Insider newsletter. What brought you back?
It was an incredibly formative experience, and I learned from the best of the best. Even just overhearing people’s phone calls or being in editorial meetings when they’re talking about these really incredible stories spanning politics and corporate deal-making and so on: I was lapping it all up. I got to hone my newsletter writing skills there, doing the daily CMO Today newsletter, which was really fun. They let me squeeze lots of puns and Britishisms in there, which was great.
I left the Wall Street Journal to try my hand at video for the first time. I was executive-producing a show at Yahoo Finance, and then I went over to Digiday. I got to work with Brian Morrissey, who’s fantastic. While at Digiday, Business Insider got in touch about potentially returning. At that point, I was itching to get back to doing that kind of big, far-reaching, widely distributed impact journalism. At that time, it was well into the Axel Springer fold after the acquisition. Business Insider was investing in growing the newsroom and producing enterprising journalism that was making me jealous.
Lucia Moses was leading the advertising reporting team at the time as its editor. She now reports on the media, entertainment, and creator beat. She’s fantastic. It seemed like a perfect time to return to what was a very different, much larger company, but it still had that energy and dynamism and the kind of famous Business Insider quirks of the startup I’d left a few years before. It was a bit like a homecoming. It’s like when you come back home after you’ve taken a year out traveling the world, and you’re ready to return.
You’ve been at Business Insider for six years, first as a media and advertising editor, and now as a senior correspondent, launching the CMO Insider newsletter in March and the CMO Insider vodcast in June. Tell us more about both!
Those are really just the start. Christian Baesler, who was interim CEO, decided to stay on as permanent CEO at Business Insider. He recently announced our new franchise strategy. People know Business Insider as having one of the largest, youngest cross-platform audiences in business journalism, and now what we’re trying to do is become indispensable with niche professional groups that we serve with exclusive reporting and other content that helps these ambitious people do their jobs better.
CMO Insider is probably the most developed of these. We’ve also got many others: Markets Insider, led by Joe Ciolli; AI Insider, which is anchored by Ali Barr; Small Business Insider, led by Kathleen Elkins; and there will be many more to come. CMO Insider started in earnest a few years ago. We’d been doing these annual lists of the most innovative CMOs, and we were doing an annual breakfast at Cannes. We thought there was more we could do with the brand to turn it into a real platform. We launched this newsletter, led by me, in March. It’s over 20,000 subscribers at this point, and each week, we’re bringing you exclusive news, scoopy analysis, and fun takes on the marketing world. I’m emptying my reporter’s notebook, and the idea is that it’s everything a CMO or budding CMO needs to know that week.
It’s not just a list of links. I’m working really hard to bring original content and make sure that when it lands in your inbox every Wednesday morning, you have to read it, or you have to set it aside to read it later, because there’s something in there that you haven’t seen anywhere else.
We piloted our podcast in June. We did three episodes, and right now we’re working on what the next iteration of that’s going to look like. So stay tuned, but it is coming back. We’re doing more social video, too. Business Insider has an incredible following on YouTube as well as TikTok and Instagram. We want to make sure the CMO Insider brand is showing up there, as well.
And there are also events. This year at Cannes, we had our flagship CMO Insider breakfast. Some of the things I enjoyed the most were the more intimate gatherings we had—things like roundtables where we convened CMOs and held their attention for an hour. They were discussing and sharing tips amongst each other. They were sharing numbers afterwards with each other. I got some story tips. It was one of the more memorable things that I did at Cannes Lions this year. We also hosted happy hours and dinners. While there, we were doing a daily edition of the newsletter. We filmed dozens of interviews with CMOs and execs in our suite, and we put out our annual list of the most innovative CMOs again.
You can expect to see CMO Insider at lots more places. Advertising Week New York is going to be the next one on the calendar, but more to come. We’re moving far beyond just text—this is really a multiplatform franchise.
Will you continue doing the Cannes CMO Insider breakfast? Any other CMO Insider events coming up, and where?
Yes, definitely. We’ll be doing the CMO Insider breakfast next year, and lots more different targeted events at Cannes. You’ve got an abundance of things to choose from at Cannes Lions, not least all the celebrities and concerts, so you’ve got to do something that’s really going to add value. We’re trying to think about what next year is going to look like. We’ll definitely be at Advertising Week New York, and we’re planning where else you might see us pop up.
With such a specific niche with CMOs, what about the function—or the marketing industry as a whole—is driving your coverage?
In my mind, every story is a marketing story if you look hard enough, and I think I’ve gotten quite good at knowing where to look. Most of the world’s biggest tech companies are funded by advertising. There are plenty of advertising stories to find about Google, Meta, Amazon, and all the others. Clearly, AI is shaking up how marketers do their jobs and create and buy ads. And there are all sorts of new players getting in on the action that weren’t even in business a few years ago that are giving the incumbent holding companies and adtech companies a run for their money.
You’ve got the quirky side of AI, too. We recently wrote about how Meta’s generative AI ad tools can often go rogue and create some really bizarre ads, like a bike with two handlebars, or randomly generating a granny to be in an ad for a menswear brand that targets trendy men. Also, we are looking at how AI is affecting those at the other end of their careers and entry-level roles, and what it means for them. We’re doing a whole lot on the creator and influencer side. That’s become a lot more important as the power of the big TV ad no longer has as much value as it once did.
There are few tentpole moments when everyone’s watching things all at once, so you’ve got to get on people’s feeds—but everyone’s feeds look different. You’ve got to get in with the creators that people want to be engaging with. The problem is that every marketer has a creator strategy, some of them with legions of creators. But when it feels like everybody is trying to sell you something or everything is a surreptitious ad, do people just go blind to it at some point? That becomes the next issue. Marketing has always been one of those industries that’s in flux, or is chasing the new thing, or is being battered by some new trend.
What are some patterns you’re seeing and some predictions you might have for the industry?
One thing we’re seeing is the maturation of some elements of the creator business. Creators are becoming media companies in their own right and owning their own IP, and I think that changes the dynamic between marketers and creators. Ultimately, the power is tipped toward the influencers in some of these negotiations.
Getting some rando with tons of followers to hold up your under-eye cream, doesn’t cut it anymore. You have to be far more integrated. I think we’re going to see more backlash against overt selling and any sort of surreptitious, not clearly labeled advertising, which is just running amok already. At some point, there needs to be a clampdown on that.
You see a lot of things like product placement and brand integrations in Hollywood. The Spider-Man movie was full of them. James Bond is always the obvious example, and I think that’s moving now more into areas like gaming. And to be honest, I think marketers often haven’t realized the power of gaming, perhaps because a lot of CMOs don’t game. We’re seeing a new class of CMOs rising who are trying out different things and rejecting some of the old ways of doing things, like the Procter & Gamble school of marketing teaches you. No offense to Procter & Gamble, but a lot of marketers come through those consumer goods companies and learn their craft there, and then apply it to different verticals.
With the ever-changing media landscape, and other publications doing CMO-specific newsletters and shows, how are you adapting Business Insider’s coverage to be more unique and stand out?
As I’ve evolved in my career, I’ve always wanted to be writing the stories that other people are not. We’re trying to make sure that CMO Insider is a trendsetter, and we’re not constantly chasing our tail or chasing other coverage. We want to be uncovering the news.
In terms of formats, we’re in discussions at the moment about how we can really up our video game at CMO Insider, and more news on that to come. You can expect to see CMO Insider doing more video to help better explain things like the thinking behind the big marketing news, or really getting to know some of the biggest movers and shakers in the business in a more fun and relatable way.
How, in your opinion, has the role of journalism changed over the past few years? What are some trends in journalism that you’re seeing, and which do you think are here to stay?
Journalists can’t be blind to the stark realities of the business side anymore, and I think too often, a lot of journalists and newsrooms didn’t pay attention to that. Of course, there are good reasons why there’s always been a church and state separation of the newsroom and commercial side. That is very healthy. I think it can be a good idea sometimes to step back and consider the marketability of what you’re producing every now and then. Is there an audience for this? That doesn’t mean you have to chase page views. You might have a niche but very valuable audience, like CMOs. Or, is this the type of thing someone might consider paying to read or handing over their email address for? Or ultimately, are those people valuable to potential sponsors?
Capital J journalists might shudder at that kind of thing. This is where the franchise model comes in. We’re not alone in doing this, but it’s new for us at Business Insider. What are we producing for our audience that provides added value beyond text on a page or beyond a website that doesn’t have the benefit of free traffic from Google and Facebook anymore? That might be the power of convening people over a dinner or a roundtable, or a podcast they listen to when they walk the dog. Or maybe it’s even just getting involved in the comment section.
You hear a lot about having this direct relationship with the audience, but I do think it’s really valuable. You see this in the waves of people breaking out from traditional media companies and striking out on their own. I think lots of journalists have actually always been quite entrepreneurial at heart. They’re ideas people. You can be very creative in how you put together a print magazine, and so on. But media institutions often didn’t give journalists the freedom to make their own destiny in this way. There were too many gatekeepers in the way, and I think that’s slowly changing—and it’s exciting.
What are the prerequisites to get coverage in the newsletter or be a guest on the vodcast? What are you looking for from CMOs?
It comes out at…

